Spoiled Food- Buy Puts In Pinnacle Foods and Post Holdings

I have been a bear on the food group since early this year. Overlapping trends of consumers shifting away from boxed and prepared foods, grocery stores cutting shelf space for these products and uber-cheap European competitors Aldi and Lidl entering the U.S., are destroying profits for the packaged food sector.

The trades:

Buy to open the December 15, 2017, put on Pinnacle Foods (PF) with a strike price of $55 at $1.75 or lower. Symbol (PF171215P55)

Buy to open the December 15, 2017, put on Post Holdings Inc. (POST) with a strike price of $85 at $2.20 or lower. Symbol (POST171215P85)

The Rationale:

Packaged food manufacturers are under increasing pressure due to weak demand from consumers and shrinking shelf space at grocery stores.

The downward spiral continues as consumer preference for fresh and prepared foods shifts dollars away from packaged foods. As grocery stores cut space for these products to make way for more popular items, orders to companies like Pinnacle and Post are hit hard.

Pinnacle’s (NYSE: PF) stock has performed better than other food stocks due to continued rumors of it being a takeover target. However, it is trading well above the highest valuations for recent food acquisitions.

Pinnacle purchased Boulder’s Brands, maker of Udi’s gluten-free pizza, in January 2016. Boulder’s sales were already declining single digits at that point and profits collapsing. Now that Pinnacle has worked through the magic of “one-time” deal charges, the true shape of its business should be apparent to investors.

The company reports its third quarter in the third week of October. Call details are below. Estimates incorporating single-digit increases in sales look too optimistic to me.

Post Holdings (NYSE: POST)  has been trying to bandage over its bleeding cereal business with massive acquisitions. In the past five months, it has announced over $3 billion of new deals, leaving little room to finance any more deals.

Its $1.8 billion purchase of British cereal maker Weetabix closed three days after the June quarter ended, so investors are not fully aware of Weetabix’s numbers. Post’s proposed $1.5 billion purchase of Bob Evans meat business has not closed yet.

The strategy of adding yet another cereal brand to a deteriorating portfolio doesn’t strike me as productive and I expect investors to be concerned when the poor sales trends for Post’s basic business are reported on its September quarter call mid-November.

The Conference Calls:

Pinnacle Foods September (Q3) Earnings Call:

Date: On or about October 25, 2017. Pinnacle announces the exact date two weeks before. I will alert you of that date as soon as it is available.

Time: 9:30 am (EST)

Call Details: Access to a live audio webcast and replay of the event will be available in the Investor Center section of the Company’s corporate website, www.pinnaclefoods.com.

What to Listen For:

  1. How much, if at all, is sales of Boulder Brands growing?
  2. How much was pricing up or down and how will the company produce higher profits in the face of price pressure?
  3. Have they come up against Aldi and Lidl in any of their markets yet and if so, how have sales fared in those geographies?

 

Post Holdings September (Q4) Earnings Call:

Date: On or about November 15. Post announces the exact date one week before. I will alert you of that date as soon as it is available.

Time: 9:00 AM (EST)

Call Details:   Interested parties are invited to listen to the webcast of the conference call, which can be accessed by visiting the Investor Relations section of Post’s website at www.postholdings.com.

What to Listen For:

  1. How much were Weetabix sales up or down in the most recent period?
  2. What are the trends in the packaged cereal business and is Post gaining or losing shelf space in grocery stores?
  3. What is the company’s plan to pay off its $9 billion debt balance? Interest payments already eat up more than one-third of earnings, what will that look like going forward?
  4. Look for terms like “brand rationalization” which is code for grocery stores demanding brands deliver great sales to save their spots on the grocery shelf.

Stock Talk

Mark F

Mark F

Linda,
I bought the recommended PF put for $1.70 and the POST for $2.05. Thanks.

Rick

Rick

Linda,

I used Bear Put Debit spreads on both:

PF Dec 57.50/52.50 Debit $1.90
POST Dec 90/80 Debit $3.35

Sanjay Gangani

Sanjay Gangani

I am new here and made my first trade on PF

Linda McDonough

Linda McDonough

Welcome, Sanjay,
Please let me know if you have any questions or comments. I’m eager to hear from PF this month.
Best,
Linda

John R

John Ryan

First trade with you, small number of contracts, 5 each.

PF 100 15 DEC 17 55 PUT @1.75
POST 100 15 DEC 17 85 PUT @2.07

John R

John Ryan

Linda, what is the target duration of this trade, I was just getting used to OFI that runs 60-90 days…

Linda McDonough

Linda McDonough

John,
Thanks for trying out PCA, I think you’ll be pleased. Officially the duration is targeted to mid-November when the stocks have a chance to digest what I expect to be poor earnings. However, if the stocks fall sooner than that, I will likely take the gain in the puts. I don’t like holding onto any options when they are within a 3-week window of expiration due to the rapid decay of the time value.
Best,
Linda

Julio Crespo-maclennan

Julio Crespo-maclennan

Dear Linda,

I have just joined PCA. I ordered 5 put contracts each for PF and POST, for the strike price of 1.75 and 2.20 but they have not been filled yet. What shall I do in these case? When you say that I must buy at a lower price, how far less shall I go.
Thank you in advance for your help and look forward to hear from you.
Best wishes,
Julio

Linda McDonough

Linda McDonough

Hello Julio,

The limit prices that I include in trade ideas mean that you should not pay a price higher than these prices. If you are able to get a lower price, that is great.

Some of the options do not trade a huge amount so choosing a price limit can be tricky. I usually suggest subscribers give themselves $.10 leeway on the limits.

For these trades that means you could pay up to $1.85 on the PF December 55 puts or up to $2.30 on the POST December 85 puts (the official price limits are $1.75 and $2.20 respectively).

Both puts are trading in these ranges so try to be patient and see if they are filled.
Please let me know if you have any other questions.

Best,
Linda

Sanjay Gangani

Sanjay Gangani

I trades three Option with your advise Linda and I am new here and just joined last week.
1) PF- i don`t think it has anymore upside … i will trade more if i get even better price
2) SCS – I think it is great buy at this price.
3) VFC- i will see how next earning will go..

I will look forward to join more trades as i goes along

Linda McDonough

Linda McDonough

Thank you for the feedback Sanjay.

I think my most happy subscribers are those that read most of my updates and analysis. There is a lot of information to cover but hopefully, I package it in a way that is easy to digest.

I do still like SmartSand here and am working on some updates on that name for next week.

Best,
Linda

Fo

Fo

With today’s alert to sell the PF puts and the earlier alert to sell the POST puts, I am out of both trades with nice profits.

Thanks, Linda, for the winners!

Add New Comments

You must be logged in to post to Stock Talk