InvestingDaily.com

Account Information

  • My Account

    Manage all your subscriptions, update your address, email preferences and change your password.

  • Help Center

    Get answers to common service questions, ask the analyst or contact our customer service department.

  • My Stock Talk Profile

    Update your stock talk name and/or picture.



Close
FEATURED STRATEGY

This Two-Minute Market Move Could Make You Rich

This Two-Minute Market Move Could Make You Rich[Revealed] How to generate instant income from the stock market. Over and over again. At will. This technique is so powerful – and safe – we’re guaranteeing you can use it to generate $1 million (or more) in retirement cash. And we’ll even send you a $1,000 check to kickstart your journey. Go here for details.

 

Amazon Chases Profits Galore

By Jim Pearce on July 7, 2017

In the classic 1964 James Bond movie Goldfinger, villain Auric Goldfinger plots to detonate an atomic bomb within Fort Knox to irradiate the U.S. gold supply. Recall that the American dollar was backed by gold in 1964 when the film was released.

As he always does, our hero is able to defeat the dastardly plan at the last second (actually, the last 0:07), thereby preventing Goldfinger from gaining a virtual monopoly on the world’s gold supply and wreaking economic havoc on the planet.

I got to thinking about that plot line after last month’s announcement by Amazon (AMZN) founder and CEO Jeff Bezos that he intends to purchase grocer Whole Foods Markets (NSDQ: WFM) to expand his company’s burgeoning food delivery service.

Share prices of most other grocers tanked immediately as shareholders feared that, like Goldfinger, Mr. Bezos might end up destroying his competition and become the only game left in town.

I don’t agree with that judgment, but not because I feel Bezos won’t be able to pull of that strategy. I have no doubt that his management team will do an excellent job of integrating Whole Foods Market into the Amazon distribution network.

What I do question is how profitable that business will turn out to be, and what that should be worth to Amazon in terms of the present value of its stock.

Amazon enjoys a mythic status on Wall Street because of the way it has systematically disrupted the entire retail industry. After dismantling the book industry, it quickly did the same for sellers of records and tapes (remember those?), and soon moved on to just about every form of merchandise that is capable of being digitized and purchased online or cheaply delivered to your door.

Amazon’s growth has been breathtaking; over the past ten years its revenue has increased more than seven-fold, accompanied by a 400% improvement in net income. But therein lays the potential problem with its business model, to wit: the company’s profit margin is a measly 1.8%.

Coincidentally, that happens to be the typical profit margin for many grocers. Even Whole Foods, sometimes derisively referred to as “whole paycheck” for the high prices it charges, can only squeeze out a profit margin of 2.5%.

So far, the reasoning behind Amazon’s huge earnings multiple is that it’s accumulating market share now that will be converted to huge profit margins later. Accordingly, in the wake of the Whole Foods announcement, AMZN’s multiple escalated to 188 times trailing earnings after its shares jumped 10%.

Similar to Mr. Goldfinger, who spent gobs of money on a private army to carry out his attack on Ft. Knox in exchange for a much greater fortune later, Bezos has spent his shareholder’s money over the past 20 years accomplishing the odd job of building arguably the world’s most sophisticated yet least profitable product delivery system.

That is an impressive feat, and one that deserves to be rewarded with a handsome share price for Amazon. But as with all things involving money, there’s a point at which the size of the current investment exceeds its future value. I believe Amazon’s purchase of Whole Foods, assuming it actually happens, is proof that there’s nothing particularly special about Amazon’s business model in terms of making money.

Here’s the upshot of the Amazon/Whole Foods merger: One company with a tiny profit margin is acquiring another company with a slightly better margin, so it can obtain a bigger market share in a very competitive business that’s essential to our daily lives. 

When Past is Prologue
I can think of a historical precedent involving mass consolidation in a critical industry that at one time was dominated by a company many people felt had acquired an insurmountable advantage in terms of market share—General Motors (NYSE: GM). Over time it acquired dozens of independent automakers, gaining market share with every purchase. As recently as 40 years ago, it still controlled more than 40% of the domestic car market.

In the case of GM, a combination of high gasoline prices and competition from overseas eventually brought it to its knees. Its once revered management team became regarded as a group of incompetent empty suits, unable to foresee the inevitable challenges that it failed to address until well after the fact.

Regardless of its true causes, the decline of GM is proof that market share alone does not ensure profitability. I suspect something similar, but less extreme, will happen with Amazon. Unless it can convert low profit businesses to higher margins, no amount of market share can justify its current valuation.

If so, then the acquisition of Whole Foods may turn out to be nothing more than proof that the most audacious plans often turn out to be the least profitable. ask Auric Goldfinger.


You might also enjoy…

 

Here’s What’s Really Going to Crush the Market

Most folks understand the basic concept of inflation… things cost more money. But tragically, most don’t understand the real implications of what it means for their financial future. 

Or just how dangerous it’s becoming right now. Today.

And there are two reasons for that…

First, the U.S. government’s calculations barely take into account two of the things you and I are paying more and more for every day: energy and food.

Second, since inflation really hasn’t been an issue for the past 30 years here in the U.S., most analysts won’t dare to say it’s on the rise because they’ll suffer professionally. 

But I’ve made a name for myself by always saying what needs to be said. Which is why I’ve prepared a new special report that’ll give you simple instructions on how to protect yourself from the coming storm.

And better still…

It gives you the full story on the six types of investments that are destined to soar 275%… 375%… even up to 575% over the next few years as the winds of inflation flatten the U.S. economy.

You can get your free copy here.

Stock Talk — Post a comment Comment Guidelines

Our Stock Talk section is reserved for productive dialogue pertaining to the content and portfolio recommendations of this service. We reserve the right to remove any comments we feel do not benefit other readers. If you have a general investment comment not related to this article, please post to our Stock Talk page. If you have a personal question about your subscription or need technical help, please contact our customer service team. And if you have any success stories to share with our analysts, they’re always happy to hear them. Note that we may use your kind words in our promotional materials. Thank you.

You must be logged in to post to Stock Talk OR create an account.

Create a new Investing Daily account

  • - OR -

* Investing Daily will use any information you provide in a manner consistent with our Privacy Policy. Your email address is used for account verification and will remain private.