Australian Consumers Continue to Spend

Although Australia’s February retail sales fell slightly short of the consensus forecast, the latest rise marked the 10th straight month of growing sales for the sector. According to the Australian Bureau of Statistics, retail turnover increased by 0.2 percent month over month versus economists’ projections of 0.3 percent.

Although February’s number fell slightly short of expectations, this performance followed January’s sales growth of 1.2 percent, which was the strongest gain in nearly a year. Given this context, one might expect consumer spending to be more restrained in the month that follows. 

On a trend basis, which removes the seasonal adjustment, February sales rose 0.7 percent, perfectly matching the increases in each of the two preceding months. In trend terms, sales grew 5.9 percent year over year.

Household goods were the largest contributor to this performance, with sales increasing by 2 percent. This category should continue to be a beneficiary of Australia’s building boom, as home sales spur demand for housewares, furniture and appliances. And that offers a perfect example of how strength in the real estate sector can flow through to other areas of the economy.

Sales from other retailing, a category which includes pharmaceutical, cosmetic and toiletry goods, as well as newspapers and books, among other subgroups, rose 1.9 percent.

Sales at cafes, restaurants and takeaway food services climbed 0.1 percent, and clothing, footwear and personal accessory retailing  also rose 0.1 percent. These results were partially offset by declines from sales at department stores, down 4.7 percent, and food retailing, which was lower by 0.2 percent.

Over the trailing three-year period, retail sales have grown an average of 0.3 percent per month, while over the trailing year retail turnover has averaged 0.5 percent per month. Despite February’s result, the retail space still clearly has near-term momentum, which is crucial as Australia’s policymakers are anxious for growth to emerge in one of the non-mining sectors.

The AUD270 billion retail sector accounts for 17 percent of Australia’s AUD1.5 trillion in annual gross domestic product (GDP) and is the second-biggest employer, providing 10 percent of the country’s jobs.

While consumers were still opening their wallets in February, there could be a possible dip in spending in subsequent months. The latest reading from the Westpac/Melbourne Institute Index of Consumer Sentiment was essentially flat, rising just three-tenths of a percentage point in April, to 99.7.

Westpac characterized the result as a mild surprise, as it had expected a stronger rebound from March’s 0.7 percent decline. That month, consumers were reeling following the announcement of mass layoffs at large firms such as the struggling airline Qantas. Economists had expected news of February’s sudden jump in employment–the economy added 47,300 jobs that month–along with the booming housing market would offset earlier doldrums.

Although April’s reading is only slightly below the three-year average of 100.8, it’s still down about 10 points from the rosy sentiment that prevailed last September during the country’s federal elections.

Among the sub-indexes, families’ assessment of their present financial condition versus a year ago showed marked improvement, up 6.7 percent month over month and 10.1 percent year over year. And their outlook for the coming year had improved 2.2 percent sequentially.

Respondents were also optimistic about the economy’s performance over the next 12 months, with the reading for this sub-index jumping 10.5 percent month over month. Their five-year outlook, however, remains somewhat gloomy. This measure declined 4.2 percent month over month and is down 12.3 percent from a year ago.

And counterbalancing the recent performance of household goods retailers, consumers’ views on whether now is a good time to buy a major household item slumped by 8.7 percent to its lowest level since May 2012.

News that the country’s housing market could be forming a bubble is also weighing on consumers. The index tracking views on whether now is the right time to buy a dwelling fell 3.9 percent and is now down 20 percent from its peak in September.

While some of these results suggest more challenges ahead, it’s important to note that consumer sentiment tends to be a lagging indicator. As Australia’s economy continues to find its footing, these measures will improve accordingly. Although consumer sentiment has fallen in a couple of key areas, these results may not comport with actual behavior, such as retail sales, which is what we’ll be watching most closely.

Portfolio Update

On April 7, retail conglomerate Wesfarmers Ltd (ASX: WES, OTC: WFAFF, ADR: WFAFY) announced it has agreed to sell the insurance broking and premium funding operations of its Insurance division to subsidiaries of Arthur J. Gallagher & Co (NYSE: AJG) for AUD1.01 billion. In addition to the purchase price, Wesfarmers will receive a distribution of approximately AUD150 million to repay funding of the premium funding operations.

Upon completion of the transaction, the AUD48.8 billion company expects to record a pre-tax profit on the sale ranging from about AUD310 million to AUD335 million. With this deal, Wesfarmers will be exiting the insurance business entirely. The sale is subject to regulatory approvals in Australia, New Zealand and the UK, a process which is expected to take several months.

The company’s insurance broking businesses include OAMPS Insurance Brokers in Australia, OAMPS UK, and Crombie Lockwood in New Zealand. The premium funding operations in Australia and New Zealand comprise Lumley Finance and Monument Premium Funding.

Wesfarmers’ latest divestiture follows the agreement announced in mid-December to sell the Australian and New Zealand underwriting businesses of its Insurance division to Insurance Australia Group (IAG). This sale is still in the midst of the regulatory review process, though one key Australian government entity recently indicated it would not oppose the deal.

Assuming both deals are ultimately consummated, the two transactions are expected to provide Wesfarmers pre-tax proceeds of approximately AUD3 billion and result in a pre-tax profit ranging from AUD1.01 billion to AUD1.085 billion.

Wesfarmers is largely a food retailer through its ownership of the Coles supermarket chain, which it acquired in a transformational deal in 2007 for AUD19 billion.

Coles accounted for AUD35.8 billion, or nearly 60 percent, of the company’s AUD59.8 billion in sales during fiscal 2013. On an EBIT (earnings before interest and taxation) basis, the Coles segment accounted for about 45.7 percent of the company’s AUD3.35 billion in total EBIT that year. By contrast, Wesfarmers’ insurance division delivered AUD2.08 billion in revenue and AUD205 million in EBIT.

In addition to the retail side of the conglomerate, which includes Coles, Kmart, Target, as well as home improvement and office supplies businesses, the Wesfarmers portfolio has industrial sector holdings in the resources, energy, chemicals and fertilizer industries. However, the firm’s industrial businesses collectively accounted for just AUD562 million, or 16.8 percent, of 2013 EBIT, so once the two pending deals are completed, the company’s retail orientation will be even more pronounced than it was previously.

As a side note, Wesfarmers was originally founded 100 years ago as a farmers’ cooperative in Western Australia, hence the name, though it has since grown into one of Australia’s largest publicly traded companies.

Management noted that the sale of Wesfarmers’ Insurance division is consistent with the company’s focus on disciplined portfolio management with regard to the long-term interests of shareholders. To that end, senior executives are weighing whether to use the proceeds to pursue an acquisition, pare debt, or return money to shareholders via a special dividend.

Shares of Wesfarmers have climbed 3.9 percent since the end of March, and now trade just 4.7 percent below their all-time high, which was hit last May.

Wesfarmers’ mix of analyst sentiment is currently weighted toward neutral, with a slightly negative tilt, at two “buys,” eight “holds,” and six “sells.” Analysts would like to see the company use the proceeds from the sale of the Insurance division to make a big acquisition that will drive future earnings growth. With the recent rally, the stock presently trades just 0.1 percent below analysts’ consensus 12-month target price of AUD42.70.

For the full fiscal-year 2014 ending June 30, analysts forecast sales will rise 4 percent year over year, to AUD61.97 billion, while adjusted earnings per share are projected to increase by 8 percent, to AUD2.12.

Operating profits are also expected to jump 12 percent, to AUD3.74 billion, a noteworthy improvement after the prior fiscal year’s decline of 2 percent.

With a yield of 4.4 percent, Wesfarmers is a buy below USD40 in the Conservative Portfolio.

Stock Talk

Add New Comments

You must be logged in to post to Stock Talk OR create an account